facebook

CoolStuffInc.com

Jurassic Sale ends Sunday!
   Sign In
Create Account

Great Magic Writing of the Week, July 27

Reddit

A staggering amount of Magic content is published each day each day on a plethora of content sites, blogs, podcasts, and discussion forums. No matter how honest an effort you make, it's easy to fall behind and miss incredible articles because there just isn't enough time to read everything.

To that end, we've collected some of the best articles of the week covering a broad range of topics. If you're looking for articles, these are the ones you don't want to miss!


On Getting Vorthos-y

Alex Ullman takes a break from his usual Cube antics to share a fantastic story about the clockwork mastermind of Conspiracy, Muzzio, Visionary Architect. What was Muzzio aspiring to when he began plotting his takeover? How do you build that story into an awesome Commander deck? Not only does Alex's article this week have a fun story and a great deck, but he ties everything together beautifully into an incredible, Vorthos-y article.

GatheringMagic.com: Alex Ullman (@nerdtothecore)- Muzzio's Grand Schematic

Inspiration. A spark. The bright candle. Call it whatever you so please, but tonight . . . tonight, it was present. There is not much to say about the myriad of moments that led up to this. I caught my likeness after a round at the local drinking establishment. For that span, a minute that stretched forever, my friends grew silent. Machines, instead, danced in my head. Wonderful winged beasts and an odd collection of gnome-like constructs. Clearly, I was blessed with something special, as many of these images are clearly not of this world.

Perhaps that dapper fellow wasn’t lying when he said he came from some place I have never heard of.

Pardon the diversion of thought. After those first flashes came, the world returned to normal speed. I knew what would come next: hours in the workshop poring over the plans for cogwork greatness half-forgotten. This time . . . this time, I would be able to craft my grand machine.


On #PTHOF Breakdown

There are a lot of players eligible for induction into the Pro Tour Hall of Fame. Every year dozens of players, judges, and community members debate the merits of all of these eligible players to determine who will end up on their Hall of Fame ballots. Career statistics, character, community contributions; all of these things have a place in this discussion, and choosing the best combination of players to vote for is a daunting task.

This week, Adam shares all of the things that affected his decisions regarding this year's ballot. Which players were seriously considered? What did Magic's best minds have to say in favor or against the eligible players? Adam compiled everything that factored into his decision and gives a fantastic perspective on the voting process.

GatheringMagic.com: Adam Styborski (@the_stybs) - Yet Another Hall of Fame Ballot, 2014 Edition

The Pro Tour Hall of Fame is a very big deal.

I don’t like to use the word very, as it’s often superfluous. I tried several opening statements, but the simplicity of using very won out. My vote as a member of the Selection Committee for the Hall of Fame is one of the few opportunities I have to shape the future of Magic.

I don’t have exact numbers, but it’s safe to say that for almost everyone reading this, the Pro Tour Hall of Fame won’t mean anything personal. Maintaining qualification for the Pro Tour is already a tough quest—earning the right to be discussed for Hall of Fame voting is a sieve that only the best players can make it through. If playing at the Pro Tour is aspirational for the average competitive player, the Hall of Fame is the reason the best keep coming back.

The fact is that, for most players, the Hall of Fame is meaningless, but for those at the top, it matters more than almost anything else. It’s prestige. It’s money. It’s byes. It’s voting “based upon the player's performances, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, and contributions to the game in general.”

...

I won’t be discussing all of them individually since others have done so already. I take all of those requirements seriously, as I said in my Hall of Fame ballot article last year: “Many of us on the Selection Committee without Pro Tour experience take our ballots with upmost sincerity and consideration.” While how the Selection and Player voting blocks work (and what that could mean) changed, my position on casting the best ballot I can hasn’t.


On Michael Jacob

Michael Jacob was a rising star on the Pro Tour several years ago, perhaps best known for his top four finish at Pro Tour Amsterdam with and awesome Cruel Control deck. More recently, Michael Jacob has become one of the most popular Magic Online streaming personalities. Michael Jacob also recently got a new job and has sold his paper collection.

Brian Demars is the person who got to buy MJ's collection. This week, Brian shares the surreal experience of sorting through the collection of a player like Michael Jacob, who he had worked with closely in the past. What do the skeletons of decks from tournaments past tell you about how Michael Jacob thinks about deckbuilding? What does it tell you about how Magic has changed?

StarCityGames.com: Brian Demars (@briandemars1) - Buying Michael Jacob's Collection

It was a bittersweet day on Tuesday when he walked into RIW Hobbies (where I work as the manager) and said, "I got the job in Denver and I leave tomorrow. I'd like to sell my collection."

Obviously, I was very happy for Mike and that he had been offered a great opportunity, but I was also a little bit saddened that he'd be moving away, and I'd likely not get to play much Magic with him anymore.

Mike has always had a close relationship with RIW, and I wasn't at all surprised that if and when he sold his collection he would bring it to us. He has more trophies on our trophy shelf than anybody else by a wide margin. Between VS System, Magic, and World of Warcraft, there are literally eight feet of MJ accomplishments.

...

As I started to go through all of the boxes that he had donated to the store, I realized something unique about Mike's collection. Most of his cards were still in "deck form," meaning that all of his cards were still in the decks where he had played them.

So as I sorted Mike's cards, I basically got to go through every single deck that MJ had ever played in the history of his entire Magic career which was an extremely interesting experience.


On Community

When you think about what it means to be a Magic player, what do you think of? Grizzled tournament veterans? Friends slinging cardboard around the kitchen table? In reality, the Magic community encompasses an incredible variety of players who all enjoy the game for slightly different reasons. This week, Danny West tries to distill all of his experiences with the Magic community to a few, fundamental truths that we can all learn something from.

StarCityGames.com: Danny West (@Tolaria_DWest) - Return of the Commander Cube

Subcultures are fascinating. The human psyche and its effect on social preference, and by extension personal comfort, creates a web in the mind of each individual that is so vast and yet so personalized that we can organize our worldwide tribe of seven billion into an infinite number of smaller groups.

Street performers. Freerunners. Those barefoot people who really love Phish.

The SCG Open in Portland recently was, in a way, a goodbye to a large part of the subculture that I spent a tremendous amount of time with over the last few years, a group to which I've belonged since I was twelve.

The imagined Magic player is an amorphous fellow, a combination of the intellectually hungry and the generic nine-to-five beer buddy. Occasionally, his beard is out of control, but on other occasions, he wears his tie sharp. Sometimes he talks Tom Ross leather jacket smooth, but other times, he's a man of many numbers who speaks only in mathematical certainties and provocative questions. Sometimes he is American angry and at others, Japanese polite. Often, he isn't a he at all, but a calendar-carrying mother of two or a giggly fourteen-year old pixie with little cat ears.

I don't know if there was ever a time when the Magic player was always the unhygienic academic, the so-called basement nerd. I don't know what kind of people I would've bought cards from all these weekends had they taken place in 1998 and not in 2011.

But for the last three years, I've shaken hands with husbands and wives and mothers and sons. And I've enjoyed it.

The title of this piece promised observational wisdom regarding our subculture and thus, I am obliged:


On M15 Limited

This year, Huey Jensen has reasserted himself as one of the greatest players ever to shuffle up some Magic cards. Huey has put up a record-breaking 8 Grand Prix Top 8's this season, including a win in Oakland. Six of those Top 8's were in Limited events, which puts Huey up at the top of the list for greatest Limited player in the game right now. With that kind of resume, it stands to reason that when Huey Jensen has some thoughts to share about Magic 2015 Limited, it's worth taking some time to listen.

ChannelFireball.com: William "Huey" Jensen (@HueyJensen) - First Impressions of Magic 2015 Limited

Even before core sets were designed with a focus on Limited, I have always enjoyed playing them. Over the weekend, I had a chance to play a prerelease with Magic 2015. I've also had the chance to do a little bit of drafting with some great Magic players and develop my understanding of the format. So far, M15 has seemed quite a bit different than its predecessor. M15 looks much more aggressive than M14, which was not very aggressive at all, much more tempo-oriented, and much less about brute forcing card advantage. The convoke mechanic has made a return in M15, and is featured on cards of every color. In this article, I'm going to explore what I believe, so far, to be the top couple commons, uncommons, and rares of each color.


On Vintage

The effect that Magic Online has on metagames and technology is interesting. With thousands of players playing tens of thousands of games every day, there's a lot of data about any given format that gets played online. Daily Events are a constant incentive to innovate, stay ahead of the format, and find new and unexpected ways to defeat your opponents. We've seen decklists and technology for Standard and Modern go from revolutionary to stock in just a week online. Formats are solved and resolved at an unbelievable pace, which leads to a dynamic and constantly evolving metagame cycle.

Vintage has never had that before. The metagame cycles slowly and has huge regional variations due to card availability and player preferences. How does that change now that Vintage is supported on Magic online? Caleb Durward takes a close look at the first few weeks of results and points out some of the awesome technology that's been developed already.

ChannelFireball.com: Caleb Durward (@CalebDMTG) - Vintage Techsplosion

For as long as I've known vintage, I've loved it. It's exciting to power out broken plays, and it's rewarding to win through whatever busted thing your opponent is doing. Sometimes you can even punish broken cards with stuff like Misdirection on an Ancestral Recall.

Mental Misstep is legal, but it's not the frustrating, oppressive card that it was in legacy because moxen lets everyone jump their curves. That Misstep has nothing on a turn one Tinker, but it does add more turn zero interaction and helps nerf Ancestral Recall and the Voltaic Key combo.

The pile of tutors available means that every deck is consistent and powerful, and the decision trees can get very deep and complex.

The problem with Vintage has always been the price tag. There are only so many pieces of power in circulation, and the collectors are so spread out that regular tournaments are few and far between. When it's the same small group of dedicated players every week or month or year, innovation will happen slowly and it might stay isolated. For as long as I remember, other format's lists have been strewn about in articles, modo results, and deck techs while vintage technology has stayed relatively buried.

Which is a shame, because some crazy things have been happening.


If you have suggestions for next week's recap you can mention us on Twitter, or share throughout the week in the comments below.


Order Magic 2015 singles, packs, and boxes at CoolStuffInc.com today!

Sell your cards and minis 25% credit bonus