Last week on our podcast, we found ourselves talking about the current Standard format and how many cards seemed underpriced, including the entire Return to Ravnica set. This got me thinking about other cards that have slowly drifted to the wayside over the past few years and just how many underpriced cards there are. For this article, I am going to venture outside of Standard and talk about some of the Eternal staples that have not been receiving enough love over the past few months—or years—and are due to take a price hike the moment they see a set of sleeves again.
Knight of the Reliquary has been a staple across formats since its debut in Conflux, but recently, over the past year, it has fallen out of favor. Most people hesitate to pick these up due to the fact that not only is there already a reprint, but it has been seeing less and less play since the downfall of Maverick. As most of you know by now, Legacy is a very circular format with an ever-shifting metagame, and although the current combo-heavy meta does not bode well for the Knight, that doesn’t mean she won’t be making a return eventually. These can currently be acquired for as little as $6 on eBay, and for that price, I feel you would be insane not to take a second look at her future. Given that this card was at $15 or more at one point, there is no reason it cannot obtain that price or higher again if she picks up any play.
Another green card I have had on my radar for a while is Natural Order. For a while, NO Bant and other similar builds were dominating the Legacy metagame while this card was topping out around $50. Just as quickly as the deck appeared, it seemed to fade into memory as Show and Tell, Reanimator, and other, faster combo decks took over. I do not believe this card should only be fetching between $25 and $30 considering just how powerful the effect is and given that each new set has the potential to break this wide open. I see no reason not to pick these up in trade. Natural Order is a card that will always be worth money, and although it has already seen two reprints, I doubt we will see a third any time soon, meaning the current price is probably the floor. I would not go looking to buy a ton of copies, but if I see them in binders and can strike a deal, I would certainly jump on the opportunity.
It seems that green is getting all the love this week, as the next card I want to cover is Green Sun's Zenith. I have been actively picking these up for almost a year now, and although they do trade out fairly well, I feel the current $4 price tag is unjustified given the power level of this card. I understand that it is banned in Modern, and that did hurt my initial reaction to it, but I quickly reevaluated this tutor and still believe it is far too cheap. With the ever-changing metagame in Legacy, it is only a matter of time before Spike wants to find his Dryad Arbor on turn one again, and when that time comes, I feel this card has nowhere to go but up, and given the current price changes, this could easily be a ten-or-more-dollar card.
Okay, I promise this is the last one . . . I think. Birthing Pod has been puzzling me for the better half of this past year, not because I don’t understand the deck or the card, but why is it only $3 to $4? I would consider this a staple in the Modern arsenal, and in any deck that does run it, you will almost always find the full four copies. With cards that are barely board-playable—such as Fulminator Mage and Wilt-Leaf Liege—reaching astronomical heights, I don’t understand why Pod is still so low. I imagine one day I will wake up and this will be a $20 card, but before that happens, I encourage you to at least go out and pick up your set if you ever plan on playing this deck in Modern.
Now that we have filled our quota for the green mage, it is time to give some of the other colors some love as well. Leyline of the Void is a card that has always held a very steady price no matter how much or little play it has seen, which doesn’t seem correct to me. With Leyline of Sanctity hitting fifteen-plus dollars, I cannot imagine the black one not taking a price hike eventually. The major strike against this one, of course, is the reprint, but I still believe $2 is far too cheap for one of the best graveyard-hate spells ever printed. On top of the fact that Leyline of the Void shuts down Dredge among a plethora of other graveyard-based decks, it is also seeing play in some of the Helm of Obedience decks again, meaning this card is no longer just board fodder. If I had to put my money on a card for highest-percentage gain over the next year or two, I would almost certainly be giving Leyline a good hard look because this guy has been a silent slayer of all things undead for a number of years, and it only seems fitting that the price reflect that.
I was trying to stray away from Standard cards this week since we covered them so heavily during the podcast; however, one card in particular has again dropped in price. Jace, Architect of Thought has now dropped below $10, and if you didn’t feel that they were a good pickup for a long term hold before, I think you would be crazy to still pass this guy up. Let’s cover the basics: His name is Jace, so he automatically has the fan-boy appeal, he costs 4 mana, meaning he is extremely playable, and to top it off, he has both the ability to lock out token strategies, slow down aggro, and he provides much-needed card advantage versus control. Had you told me when Jace was first spoiled that he would be $10 while he was still legal in Standard, I would have laughed. It is in fact a sad day we live in when one of the best ’walkers ever printed is less than his 5-mana double-printed equivalent. I will digress since I could have written my whole article about how good this guy is and what the likelihood is of him hitting $20 or more during his remaining time in Standard, but beyond that, he is also beginning to break into Modern, meaning his price may not even fall off once his two years in the spotlight are up.
The last card I want to talk about this week is a little out of left field, but I feel that it has been neglected since its reprint as a Grand Prix foil. Maelstrom Pulse has been picking up in recent years as the go-to catch-all for B/G, and although the reprint does hurt the price, I feel the $10 price tag is lower than it could be. If Vindicate, which sees little to no play, can be a $30 card, why isn’t this $20? I don’t believe the card will suddenly spike as with many of the others I have mentioned this week, but I do see a steady increase over the coming years, making it a very solid long-term pick up. If Modern continues to increase in popularity, we may see this price achieved sooner rather than later, but either way, it seems to be a reasonable pickup if you think about it during a trade. The only thing that makes me hesitant to go to deep on Pulse is the fact that it may be in Modern Masters, but frankly, if that stopped me from picking up cards, I wouldn’t be able to stock for Pro Tour Qualifiers out of fear that all my cards would be price-slashed come June. I don’t believe that enough Modern Masters will be printed to fill the current demand, much less the future need once stores start regularly holding Modern Friday Night Magic. Even if the cards do drop in the short term, I don’t expect there to be too hard of a long-term hit, making almost anything in Modern still safe pickups.
If you have any cards that you believe are criminally underpriced, please post your opinion in the comment section below, and share your ideas as to why. I think the most important part of this game is the community aspect, and that includes the financial realm, so take some time to let people know why you are investing in certain cards or dumping others. I am but one voice in a pool of many, and there is no way I can cover every card, so I encourage each of you to think of a card and a reason and post it, and if you are so inclined, feel free to leave feedback on others as well. That’s all the time we have this week—join me next week as always, as we cover more up-to-date financial information. If you have any questions or comments, feel free to tweet me or leave a comment below.
Ryan Bushard