Today’s Sealed Deck competition is a step away from the ordinary. Instead of getting the expected six booster packs from a single block, you and the other participants received one booster pack of each Standard-legal expansion with which to make a deck. That’s one pack each of Khans of Tarkir, Fate Reforged, Dragons of Tarkir, Magic Origins, Battle for Zendikar, and Oath of the Gatewatch.
Needless to say, your deck-building turned out . . . interesting. With your stronger cards spread across multiple colors, you opted for a Jeskai deck in order to try to play everything. Strangely, it’s been playing a lot better than you expected.
You’re now playing against Mustaba in the second round of the tournament. You won your first game through the use of some very timely combat tricks, and your opponent has been second-guessing you ever since. This has had mixed results: You don’t have as many instants as Mustaba probably thinks you do, but the fact that he’s been delaying his attacks also means that his defense has been tough to crack.
It doesn’t look like Mustaba’s going to hold back for much longer though. On his previous turn, he tapped most of his lands to play a Plated Crusher, and now he’s eyeing the life total scribbled on your score pad. You don’t think you can get rid of the Crusher fairly easily either—even if you did have some convenient removal in hand, hexproof is a really nasty ability.
Going into your draw phase, it’s obvious you need something that will change the scope of the game. Unfortunately for you, a Makindi Aeronaut is not exactly what you had in mind.
Looking at the board again, however, you see a possible line of play. It’s a little blurry on the details, but it’s definitely there—and, well, you’ll figure it out as you go along. Mustaba may be planning to make something happen on his next turn, but you’ll be making sure that it doesn’t get that far.
It is the beginning of your first main phase. Defeat Mustaba this turn.
You are at 5 life with the following cards in play:
- Kor Bladewhirl
- Scaldkin
- Chasm Guide
- Living Lore (exiling Howl of the Horde)
- 3 Islands
- 2 Mountains
- Plains
- Mystic Monastery
You have the following cards in your hand:
- Turn to Frog
- Brute Strength
- Makindi Aeronaut (drawn during your draw step this turn)
You have not yet played a land this turn. You do not know the identity of any of the cards that are currently on top of your library.
Mustaba is at 9 life and has no cards in his hand. He has the following cards in play:
- Sky Scourer
- Shambling Ghoul
- Malakir Familiar
- Alpine Grizzly
- Abzan Kin-Guard
- Plated Crusher
- 4 Swamps (three tapped)
- 4 Forests (all tapped)
If you think you have a great solution in mind, don’t put it in the comments! Instead, send it to puzzles at gatheringmagic dot com with the subject line “Puzzle — He Who Hesitates”. We’ll include the best ones in next week’s article along with the next puzzle!
Last Week’s Puzzle
Correct solutions to last week’s puzzle were received from Russell Jones, Norman Dean, Jonathan Kustina, Ryou Niji, Andrew Muravskyi, John Broky, Chadwick Bond, Matthew Siff, Sanjay Saith, David Foodym, Luciano Robino, Tim Reinholz, David Solomon, Kriz Lee, Aaron Golas, Aaron Tesler, Quadrangolo Tetra, Dorian Sinclair, Nate Burgess, Subrata Sircar, Bob Wilson, and Bill Murphy.
“The key to the whole thing is Faces of the Past,” Dorian Sinclair writes, “which, when combined with some careful sequencing, can remove our opponent's ability to block flyers entirely, and (thanks to its interaction with Phantom Nantuko and our very lucky top-deck) gives us the power in the air we need to take advantage of that.”
We’ll need to get up to speed first, though—Andrew Muravskyi points out that several cards in the puzzle have seen updates from their original printing: “The long trawl across Gatherer brings us the following list of Faces of the Past interactions:
- Phantom Nantuko and Insect tokens are, well, Insects.
- Phantom Nantuko and Krovikan Horror are Spirits.
- Spawnbroker and Rashka the Slayer are Humans.
- Krovikan Horror and Dread Reaper are Horrors.
This, of course, assumes you have a way to send creatures to the graveyard. Fortunately, Summer’s Krovikan Horror fits the bill nicely, and all you have to do is get it on your side of the table.
“Unfortunately,” Andrew adds, “our three spells cost 8 mana (Krosan Groundshaker isn't castable and should become Imp fuel), and this would mean only one Horror activation, which won’t be enough. Spawnbroker is required to steal the Horror, and Fate Transfer is a yummy combat trick; therefore, Hysterical Blindness should also be relegated to Imp fodder.”
This leads up to Bob Wilson’s solution, which involves feeding two cards to the Putrid Imp:
- Discard Krosan Groundshaker to give Putrid Imp flying. Then, discard Hysterical Blindness to give it flying again . . . just in case. More importantly, that makes seven cards in our graveyard, so Putrid Imp becomes a 2/2 and can no longer block.
- Cast Spawnbroker, exchanging control of our Putrid Imp (2 power) and Summer's Krovikan Horror (also 2 power). Summer only has 5 cards in her graveyard, so her Putrid Imp shrinks back to a 1/1 and regains the ability to block. It still has flying and flying though.
- Tap Phantom Nantuko to have it put a third +1/+1 counter on itself.
- Sacrifice Symbiotic Elf to Krovikan Horror, dealing 1 damage to the Junún Efreet. We make two Insect tokens.
- Sacrifice an Insect token to the Horror, pinging the Efreet again. Have Faces of the Past untap both the second Insect token and the Phantom Nantuko. Tap the Nantuko to have it put a fourth +1/+1 counter on itself.
- Sacrifice the second Insect token to the Horror, pinging the Efreet one more time, killing it. Have Faces of the Past untap the Nantuko; tap it for a fifth +1/+1 counter.
- Sacrifice the Krovikan Horror to itself, targeting Spawnbroker. Have Faces of the Past tap both the Dread Reaper and the already-tapped Phantom Nantuko. When the Horror's ability resolves, Spawnbroker will die—have Faces tap Rashka the Slayer.
- Use our 2 remaining mana for Fate Transfer, moving all of the Phantom Nantuko’s counters to the Nephalia Seakite.
- Attack with the 7/8 flying Seakite. Junún Efreet is dead, Rashka and Dread Reaper are tapped, and Putrid Imp can't block since Summer now has seven cards in her graveyard.
- Nephalia Seakite crashes in and puts Summer to 0, ending the game.
“Realizing that one of the Horror activations needed to damage one of our own creatures was a breakthrough,” Chadwick Bond muses, “since we need the Elf, both Insect tokens, Spawnbroker, and the Horror itself to all die from four activations. It was clear we needed to kill Junún Efreet since Faces wasn't able to tap him, but that left 1 stray damage left over.”
Even so, a variant solution exists in which you can leave one of your Insect tokens alive, with the key insight being the fact that you can target an opponent’s creatures with Fate Transfer. Luciano Robino demonstrates:
- Tap Phantom Nantuko to have it put a +1/+1 counter on itself.
- Cast Spawnbroker and exchange Phantom Nantuko for Krovikan Horror.
- Pay and sacrifice Spawnbroker to make Krovikan Horror deal 1 damage to Junún Efreet.
- Since a Human died, tap Rashka the Slayer with Faces of the Past.
- Pay and sacrifice Symbiotic Elf to make Krovikan Horror deal 1 damage to Junún Efreet. You put two 1/1 Insect tokens into play. You now also have seven cards in your graveyard, so Putrid Imp is a 2/2 creature.
- Pay and sacrifice Krovikan Horror to make Krovikan Horror deal 1 damage to Junún Efreet, killing it.
- Since a Horror Spirit died, tap Dread Reaper and Phantom Nantuko with Faces of the Past.
- Cast Fate Transfer on Phantom Nantuko to give Putrid Imp three +1/+1 counters.
- Discard a card (either Hysterical Blindness or Krosan Groundshaker) to give Putrid Imp flying.
- Swing with Putrid Imp (5/5) and Nephalia Seakite (2/3) for the kill.
Then again, both of these solutions assume that you need to clear the skies completely. Aaron Golas points out that using Krovikan Horror’s ability on Summer means that you can leave the Junún Efreet alive:
- Tap Phantom Nantuko to have it put a +1/+1 counter on itself.
- Cast Spawnbroker. When it enters the battlefield, exchange control of Phantom Nantuko and Krovikan Horror.
- Pay and sacrifice Spawnbroker to have Krovikan Horror deal 1 damage to Summer. Faces of the Past triggers and taps Rashka the Slayer.
- Repeat by sacrificing Symbiotic Elf, one of the Insect tokens it leaves behind, and finally Krovikan Horror itself. Faces of the Past triggers in all three cases: tap all Elves, Insects, and Horrors (Dread Reaper becomes tapped), respectively. Summer goes to 3 life.
- Discard a card to give Putrid Imp flying; this also puts you at threshold, giving Putrid Imp +1/+1.
- Attack with Putrid Imp and Nephalia Seakite. Summer can block one with Junún Efreet.
- Cast Fate Transfer to move all of Phantom Nantuko's counters onto your unblocked creature to deal Summer 5 damage.
“The Fate Transfer you drew this turn isn't even strictly necessary,” Aaron adds. “Follow the solution as above, but sacrifice your second Insect token to Krovikan Horror instead of leaving up mana for Fate Transfer. Now your attack only needs to deal 2 damage to Summer, and both of your attackers naturally have 2 power.”
“It's really poetic how we needed to combine both artists' cards to complete the win,” Kriz Lee observes. “Thank you, Christopher Rush and Wayne England. May you both rest in peace and know you left an everlasting legacy.”